I remember a client who tried to launch their new user interface without testing it properly. They were confident everything would go smoothly — until the user feedback came in. It was a reality check. What the design team thought was intuitive? It didn’t land with actual users.
That’s when it hit me: It’s not enough to rely solely on user input. You’ve got to step back and assess the interface from an expert’s perspective, too.
Enter heuristic evaluations.
While user feedback is great, it tends to stay on the surface. Heuristic evaluations let experts dive deeper, spotting usability issues early and measuring the design against tried-and-true usability principles. I see it as a proactive way to catch problems before they snowball into bigger ones. I’ll explore everything you need to know about heuristic evaluations below.
Table of Contents
What is a Heuristic Evaluation?
A heuristic evaluation is a usability test where experts assess an interface based on a set of principles, called heuristics. It helps product developers ensure a website or app is user-friendly by conducting evaluations throughout the development process.
Heuristic evaluations provide product development teams with an expert assessment of their website's usability. After the inspection, evaluators give developers and designers a list of potential issues to address.
From there, developers and designers take those insights and make tweaks to improve the overall user experience. When done right, heuristic evaluations can uncover and solve over 80% of usability issues, making it an essential step in creating a smooth and intuitive interface.
.png)
Free UX Research Kit + Templates
3 templates for conducting user tests, summarizing your UX research, and presenting your findings.
- User Testing Template
- UX Research Testing Report Template
- UX Research Presentation Template
Download Free
All fields are required.
Heuristic Evaluation vs. Usability Testing
Both heuristic evaluations and usability tests help uncover usability issues, but the way they’re done — and what they find — are pretty different. Let me break it down for you.
Heuristic evaluation is conducted by industry professionals who use a set of guidelines to evaluate a website or app. These evaluators go through the interface themselves and flag anything that doesn’t meet best practices. They then hand over a list of recommendations to the development team.
Usability testing, on the other hand, puts real users in the driver’s seat. They're given specific tasks to complete while evaluators watch how it goes—did they finish it, and how long did it take? Sometimes, users are asked for feedback, but it’s usually based on what the dev team wants to know.
To put things into perspective, heuristic evaluation relies on expert judgment, while usability testing gets insights straight from the users themselves.
When to Use a Heuristic Evaluation
You can use a heuristic evaluation at any point in the product development process. However, it‘s most effective when conducted early on in the website or app’s design stages.
Pro tip: I recommend performing heuristic evaluations after every design sprint. This way, your team will have useful feedback about your design before users are exposed to it during testing.
Moreover, heuristic evaluations are more affordable to conduct when the interface is in the early stages of development. The more advanced your interface becomes, the more expensive it will cost to redesign it.
By running your heuristic evaluations early and often, you can ensure usability and avoid costly redesigns.
The Benefits of Conducting a Heuristic Evaluation
There are many usability tests you can conduct. However, heuristic evaluations provide unique insights that play a major role in the success of your website or app.
Additionally, they can be much more cost-effective and efficient compared to other testing methods.
This should be enough to sway most product teams. But if you're still on the fence, let me walk you through three key benefits that might change your mind.
1. Efficiency
Heuristic evaluations, in practice, are a relatively simple process to conduct. Depending on the product's complexity, they can be completed in as little time as a couple of days.
Experts who analyze the interface often work independently. This allows developers to focus on other projects while the evaluators work.
Once the evaluation is complete, designers can then address the errors found in testing. After corrections are made, they can present another version for evaluators to re-test. This creates an efficient feedback loop that continues throughout the development process.
2. Organization
The feedback from a heuristic evaluation can influence how a team prioritizes sprints and projects.
Evaluators provide product management with a list of flaws, organized by their severity. Product owners can use this information to create and sort out their product backlogs.
By using this system for prioritization, product teams are more likely to stay organized and meet their deadlines.
3. Versatility
Heuristic evaluations aren't a one-and-done analysis. Their findings can be used alongside other usability tests to uncover fresh insights.
For example, after addressing the feedback from a heuristic evaluation, you can check out your product usage reports to measure the success of your changes.
If you notice areas of lower usage, you can then point out those aspects to evaluators.
Heuristic evaluations also provide product developers with qualitative feedback. This helps explain trends appearing in product usage reports.
How to Conduct a Heuristic Evaluation
The specifics of a heuristic evaluation vary based on the type of service or application you're testing. However, I recommend following these seven common steps to run an effective evaluation:
How to Run a Heuristic Evaluation
- Determine what you're testing.
- Clearly define context and goals.
- Select a team of evaluators.
- Choose your heuristics.
- Give evaluators specific instructions.
- Conduct multiple evaluations.
- Collect results.
1. Determine what you're testing.
The first step in a heuristic evaluation is determining exactly what you're testing. This means narrowing the scope to keep the evaluation focused.
For example, if I’m testing an ecommerce website, I could hone in on the product search function, the checkout flow, or the overall navigation. This saves me from going in circles and makes the findings more actionable.
2. Clearly define context and goals.
Next, I set the stage by defining the purpose.
Am I looking to improve user satisfaction? Maybe I’m trying to boost conversion rates or streamline first-time user experiences.
Let’s stick with my ecommerce example — if the goal is to reduce cart abandonment, then everything I evaluate will zero in on that. It helps keep the evaluation on target.
3. Select a team of evaluators.
Here, I'll choose a team of evaluators who know heuristic principles and have experience in UX or interface design.
For my ecommerce site, I’d ideally bring in UX designers who’ve worked on retail platforms. The team size will vary, but I recommend going for at least two evaluators to avoid bias — any more than ten can make the data harder to handle.
4. Choose your heuristics.
With the goals and team set, I‘ll then choose a heuristic framework. If you’re stuck, you can rely on a common framework, such as Molich and Nielsen. This model covers areas like consistency, feedback, error prevention, and flexibility.
In my ecommerce evaluation, for example, I'll ask my team to ensure the checkout process is intuitive and frustration-free.
5. Give evaluators specific instructions.
Before evaluators begin, they should have clear instructions on:
- what they'll be testing
- which rating scales to use
- how to flag any issues they come across during the process
In my ecommerce case, I’d ask evaluators to perform a typical task, like searching for a product and completing a purchase. I’d also guide them on how to log issues, like unclear error messages or clunky navigation.
6. Conduct multiple evaluations.
Multiple evaluations allow for a deeper and more refined analysis. In the first evaluation, the team may freely explore the interface. In subsequent evaluations, they will hone in on specific usability problems and flag those for review.
For instance, in the first pass of my e-commerce website, an evaluator might spot a confusing product filter. During the second pass, they would dive deeper into how that issue affects the shopping experience and provide detailed feedback.
7. Collect results.
Finally, I'll collect the evaluators’ reports and go over them together.
Let’s say the team finds that users frequently struggle with a missing guest checkout option, causing cart abandonment. I’d make fixing that a priority to boost conversions.
Pro tip: Consider using HubSpot's Free UX Templates to pull everything together after a heuristic evaluation. They make it easy to capture all the important details, spot patterns, and rank the issues that need fixing. Plus, it’s a breeze to share clear recommendations with the team or stakeholders, so everyone is on the same page.
Heuristic Evaluation Best Practices
Use these five best practices to ensure accuracy and consistency in your heuristic evaluations:
Heuristic evaluation best practices
1. The earlier you start, the better.
Conduct heuristic evaluations as early as possible, ideally after the functional prototypes are ready.
At this stage, making design changes is more flexible and cost-effective. Early evaluations can catch critical usability issues before they become ingrained in the product, saving you from costly reworks down the line.
2. Keep the focus narrow.
Rather than trying to evaluate everything at once, zero in on a specific set of functions or even a single function. This focused approach allows evaluators to provide deeper, more actionable feedback.
By honing in on critical areas, you can drive improvements quickly and iterate on them early.
3. Choose the right heuristics.
Not every heuristic will be right for your evaluation.
For example, one of Molich and Nielsen‘s heuristics is the provision of clearly marked exits when users click on the wrong link. If you’re evaluating products that have just come out of prototyping, these exits may not be in place. This measurement, therefore, provides no value.
Instead, choose heuristics relevant to the current product stage to avoid irrelevant feedback and focus on aspects that genuinely need your attention.
4. Create a consistent scale.
Consistency in scoring — whether it’s a 1-10 scale, percentage, or yes/no — ensures you can compare feedback across different evaluators and features. You can aggregate findings effectively and prioritize fixes.
In contrast, inconsistent scales create ambiguity, making it difficult to pinpoint where the most significant issues lie.
5. Remember the role of heuristic evaluation.
Remember that heuristic evaluation isn't a replacement for end-user testing.
Sure, heuristic evaluations help identify key interface usability issues. However, this narrow focus means they can't provide broader behavioral insights, like other end-user evaluations.
Be sure to combine heuristic insights with feedback from actual users to get a holistic view of your product’s performance.
Fostering Feedback With a Heuristic Evaluation
Heuristic evaluations are the perfect starting point when you're building an app or service.
When I first learned about heuristic evaluations, I was surprised by how quickly they flagged critical usability issues that would have otherwise slipped under the radar. I‘ve seen firsthand how starting with this method can reveal major usability issues right off the bat, giving you a chance to fix things before users even experience frustration. This way, when you finally get customer feedback, it’s more about fine-tuning than tackling big problems. A sure win!
Editor's note: This post was originally published in March 2019 and has been updated for comprehensiveness.
Free UX Research Kit + Templates
3 templates for conducting user tests, summarizing your UX research, and presenting your findings.
- User Testing Template
- UX Research Testing Report Template
- UX Research Presentation Template
Download Free
All fields are required.
![5 Qualitative Research Methods Every UX Researcher Should Know [+ Examples]](https://www.hubspot.com/hubfs/qualitative%20reseach%20methods_featured.png)
![How the Serial Position Effect Influences Your Users [Cheat Sheet]](https://www.hubspot.com/hubfs/shoppers%20making%20purchasing%20decisions%20off%20of%20the%20serial%20position%20effect.jpg)
