11 Skills to Look for When Hiring a Social Media Agency

Download Now: Free Marketing Plan Template
Young Entrepreneur Council (YEC)
Young Entrepreneur Council (YEC)




Having a strong social presence can really help your brand, and though anyone can go online and create a Facebook page or post a few Tweets, that’s not the best way to grow a loyal customer base.

So when vetting a social media agency, what should you look for? What traits and skills are needed to ensure your success? We asked 11 founders what competencies they in particular looked for when hiring a social media agency.

1) Engagement

Make sure that the social media agency is actually getting engagement in things they are doing. Anyone can manage a social media account, but few can manage it and get a lot of engagement. Make sure that they can prove results and show you from their experience that they can do the same for you and your business.

John Rampton, JohnRampton.com

2) Heart

Any agency can handle the mechanics around social media. I look for companies that demonstrate a huge amount of heart and care for the work they do. I want deep thinkers who are only working with organizations with whom they are aligned. I look for companies that know what they stand for, are bold with their ideas and are dynamic with their execution. All of that is heart -- they've got to have it.

Corey Blake, Round Table Companies

3) Customer Service

Customers often hit up social media when they have a complaint. You need a considerable amount of tact and foresight to make sure to satisfy the customer and all parties reading it.

Elliot Bohm, Cardcash.com

4) Client Relationship Skills

Social media agencies are almost always more expensive than hiring top global talent to work remotely and only paying the hours they bill. The one thing a social media agency could have on remote talent is client relationship management. That means being responsive, managing the relationship in a way that shows that the client is important and always following through on promises.

Dave Nevogt, Hubstaff.com

5) Facility With Numbers

The difference between an effective social media agency and an ineffective one comes down to their use of numbers to track actual business impact. A lot of social media workers get lost in the likes, fans and comments and lose sight of the actual business goals that these actions should be driving. If a clear path can be shown to drive business, the agency can move needles in a big way.

Brennan White, Cortex

6) Understanding of My Niche

One of the biggest challenges when hiring a social media agency is finding an agency that understands your niche and your target audience. There is a synergy that happens when the social media team understands the nuance of your niche, and those who do will be able to craft effective messages and ultimately get the best results.

Nicole Munoz, Start Ranking Now

7) Ownership

Your social media agency should understand and take ownership of your brand as much as you would. They should care about your success, your customers and your employees, and how all of these play a role in your social media presence. The social media role should not be given to a vendor, but rather, to a trusted partner of your business.

Angela Harless, AcrobatAnt

8) Clear Understanding of Technology and Data

Data-driven decisions are the gold standard in management today. You want a social media agency that is able to take advantage of cutting-edge technology and techniques while also keeping track of data and other metrics. That way, you can easily see what is working and what is not in your marketing plan and be able to cut or expand on certain strategies.

Firas Kittaneh, Amerisleep

9) Respectful Creativity

If you are going to run our social media campaigns and daily updates, I want to see some creativity -- something to set us apart. I want to see new and exciting activities that will create an online community surrounding our brand, something that will make us recognizable. However, this creativity must be carried out with respect to what our brand's values are and what we have already become.

Miles Jennings, Recruiter.com

10) Speed

Social media demands a faster pace than websites, banners, print, TV, or billboards. Great social campaigns run at the speed of conversation. So a social agency must be built to iterate and deliver creative quickly. Full disclosure: I lead a social media agency, so I hope my clients hold us to this standard.

Alec McNayr, McBeard Media

11) Proactive Analytics

Even the strongest creativity needs A/B comparisons and in-depth analysis to reach its full potential. Social marketing is still marketing.

Sam Saxton, Salter Spiral Stair and Mylen Stairs

These answers were provided by members of Young Entrepreneur Council (YEC), an invite-only organization comprised of the world’s most promising young entrepreneurs. In partnership with Citi, YEC recently launched StartupCollective, a free virtual mentorship program that helps millions of entrepreneurs start and grow businesses.


Topics: Agency Talent

Related Articles

We're committed to your privacy. HubSpot uses the information you provide to us to contact you about our relevant content, products, and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information, check out our Privacy Policy.


Outline your company's marketing strategy in one simple, coherent plan.

Marketing software that helps you drive revenue, save time and resources, and measure and optimize your investments — all on one easy-to-use platform