For years, there’s been a debate raging in the sales community: When reaching out to a prospect for the first time, should you call or email?

After all, first interactions with prospects are key -- you’re aiming to establish trust, provide value, gather key information, and perhaps even secure a follow-up meeting. If you don’t use the right medium, they’ll be less receptive to your message (and that’s assuming they engage at all).

Luckily for sales reps everywhere, more than 20 sales experts and practitioners on Quora decided to weigh in.Register for our free sales panel discussion on how to crush the start of your  2019 sales year.

When In Doubt, Email First

The majority of experts recommended starting with an email. “An initial email usually makes more sense because it doesn't require [the prospect to] answer at the moment they receive it,” writes Robert Graham, author of Cold Calling Early Customers.

Plus, as others pointed out, you can use an email as a reason to call.

“I always start by referring to this first email to show we're one step further in our relationship,” explains Stan Frering, head of Client Relationship Management for Easytrip France.

Emailing has a third advantage over calling, according to EchoSign co-founder Jason Lemkin. It lets you educate your prospect on the product’s value proposition, and clearly connect it with the prospect’s situation.

“The prospect needs to understand the value proposition first,” he explains. “It needs to be very strong, and very clear. No one will take a random call about a product they've never heard of it's not 100% crystal clear they have a huge, pre-defined need for it.”

When to Ignore the Email-First Rule

However, there is one exception to the “email first” rule.

Lemkin says once your brand has been established, it’s time to start calling your prospects.

“If your prospect has already heard of [your company], they'll know if they want to speak to you about the product and learn more about buying,” Lemkin writes.

For example, say you’re a salesperson for Dropbox. You call a prospect and say, “Hi John, I’m with Dropbox, and I noticed your CEO tweeted that your company is almost out of free virtual storage. I’d love to discuss how we could get you some more so you can keep all your files in one place.”

John already knows Dropbox and understands why it’s a useful product -- so he’s got a good reason to stay on the phone.

However, if you were selling a brand-new cloud storage solution, Lemkin argued that it would be better to send John an email first so he has more time to consider your value prop.

Not sure how much clout your company name carries? To quickly gauge brand awareness, go to Google Trends and compare how many people are searching for your company versus your top competitors. If your company gets the most searches, that means it probably has the highest name recognition in your space.

A Better Method Than Phone Or Email?

But to one expert, the question of “phone vs. email” is innately flawed.

SVP at LivePerson Sean Burke says that, in fact, your default shouldn’t be calling or emailing. He recommends using your network to get an introduction -- great advice, considering that having a referral makes a buyer five times more likely to engage.

“You'd be surprised how often this crucial first step is ignored,” Burke writes.

Once your mutual connection has agreed to introduce you, ask him or her which communication method the prospect prefers. Most people have an individual preference for calling or emailing.

However, if you don’t have a shared connection, Burke suggests looking at the prospect’s social media presence. If she is “social” -- meaning she’s got 500-plus LinkedIn connections and an active Twitter or Instagram account -- use those channels to interact with her and start adding value. If she’s “traditional” -- meaning she doesn’t meet those criteria -- Burke gives you the go-ahead to call or email.

Whatever You Do, Don’t Cold Call or Spam

While opinions differed on the relative merits of calls vs. email vs. social media, the experts were unanimous on one point: You should never reach out to a prospect via any channel without doing research first.

“Ultimately, you are in a much better position -- either calling or emailing -- if you have background information on the person you are contacting,” notes Jeremy Boudinet, head of marketing for Ambition. “That way, you can tailor your message off the bat, since you have an idea of how you can add value to that person or company.”

Sales Email or Sales Call? Experiment and Find Out

Although these guidelines should definitely guide your prospecting strategy, don’t forget they’re just that: guidelines. “Why not take a test-and-learn approach to this problem?” writes Nick Dellis, Weebly’s VP of Business Development. “What works for you may not work for others.”

Dellis suggests emailing first, then calling with 10 to 20 prospects, doing the reverse with another 10 to 20 prospects, and comparing the results.

“Taking this approach of testing ideas and optimizing is the only way to find out for yourself,” he says. “And it’ll help you be a better salesperson in the longer term.”

Do you call or email first? Do you agree with the “email-first” rule? Tell us in the comments.

Register Now

 Register for our free panel discussion.

  Try HubSpot Sales

Originally published Jun 25, 2018 9:43:00 AM, updated November 09 2018

Topics:

Sales Prospecting