That's right. Sometimes truly great content flops. And to be honest, it's a big disappointment (and a damn shame). The silver lining is, there's usually a pretty good explanation for why that particular piece of content failed to spread, and understanding some of the top reasons why great content fails can put you on a righteous path that enables you to succeed with future pieces of great content.
And if anything positive can come from failure, it's a good lesson or two. We've come in contact with a few content failures in our experience as content creators, so we've nailed down 6 compelling reasons -- and lessons to learn from -- why great content fails.
1. The Topic Isn't Appropriately Targeted
When it comes to successful content, the topic/idea is everything. You can write the most amazing piece of content and make it the best it can be, but that doesn't mean it will be enough. One of the core reasons great content fails is because the topic was the wrong one. It could be "wrong" for a number of reasons. Maybe it's not a topic that is appropriately targeted toward the audience it's being presented to. Maybe it's targeted, but it's just not a topic your audience would necessarily think is interesting.
How to Avoid Failure: Spend the time to make sure the topic and idea has the potential to be successful. A major part of this is truly understanding your target audience and marketing personas, and analyzing the topics and ideas that have resonated with that audience in the past. Your analytics are your best friend here, so leverage them!
2. The Title or Headline is Crappy
A great piece of content hidden behind a crappy title or headline is just that -- hidden. The title of your content is a potential reader's first impression of that content, whether they find a link to your content in social media, search results, or via email. If you're headline isn't enticing enough to get that reader to click on and view your content, it's doomed to fail.
How to Avoid Failure: Put some solid effort into learning how to write awesome titles for your content. A great headline is actionable, brief, keyword-conscious, clear, definitive, and intriguing. Master the art of exceptional blog titles, and you'll be one step closer to preventing content failure.
3. There Is No Attention to Detail
The topic of your content, the ideas you present, and the way in which you present them may all be top-notch, but it's amazing how simple details like spelling and grammar can easily ruin an otherwise amazing piece of content. Don't undermine the importance of paying attention to these types of details when pulling together a final draft of your content.
How to Avoid Failure: Always, I repeat, ALWAYS have a colleague or teammate (preferably one who has an eye for details) proofread and edit your work. It's stupidly silly to let a great piece of content go to waste because of a few easily preventable typos.
4. It Isn't Promoted
Trust a recovering content marketer --if you build it, that doesn't necessarily mean they will come. Without any promotion, your awesome content is basically stuck on an island. And the only thing it will have to keep it company is the other lonesome content on your blog or website. Don't fall victim to the common assumption that great content will just naturally get stumbled across. In order for great content to be truly successful, it needs a little help.
How to Avoid Failure: Get your content out there, for goodness' sake! Send that awesome new ebook you wrote to your email database, and share your latest blog article with your fans and followers in social media!
5. It's Not Socially Enabled
Successful content isn't just proactively promoted by its author. It's also promoted by readers who love the content and want to share it with their networks. Successful content makes it easy for readers and viewers to share in the first place by offering social media sharing buttons in obvious places.
How to Avoid Failure: Add social media sharing links/buttons to every piece of content you produce in obvious places. People are lazy. Make it mind-numbingly simple for them to share if they want to. Chances are, if you put the buttons right in front of them, they'll use them, giving your content more exposure to potentially interested content consumers. Research shows that including a Twitter share button on your content leads to 7x more mentions!
6. It's Not Optimized for Search
One of the best ways to generate organic visibility for your content is to make sure it's optimized for search. Your prospects are looking for and finding content via search. If your content isn't optimized well enough to show up in their search results, it's not going to get found there. Without proper search engine optimization, your content is at great risk of failure.
How to Avoid Failure: Conduct keyword research to identify appropriate keywords for your business. Then search engine optimize your content by sprinkling those keywords throughout -- in page titles, header tags, and throughout the body of your content.
What are some other reasons great content fails to spread?
Image Credit: Kevin Jarrett
Erika Barbosa 7:00 PM on November 10, 2011
Another big reason why content fails is because of the formatting. You have to make your content digestible to the eye. For some readers, if the content looks like a big undertaking just to scan the article, they may just move on to another article altogether. Formatting such as bullet points and breaking up the copy helps a great deal.
nick goddard 1:46 AM on November 11, 2011
Nice article - I also get frustrated by blogs which don't allow comments or interaction, as they are surely missing a trick to engage.
Nikhil 3:12 AM on November 11, 2011
Six points very well put, but the real world works in far stranger ways - especially with reference to why great content often fails. Where I belong, the perception is almost as though writing, editing and optimizing website content is not such a big deal as programming, web/website development, other technical stuff...and website designing, of course. See the parallel?
Now that's what the real world is all about. You never really know what factors are affecting your content because there are way too many.
But these six are definitely ones to watch out for.
Good job!
Do keep it up, Ms. Vaughan.
Mark 11:43 AM on November 11, 2011
I would also argue that content fails because it is not fresh, timely or engaging.
One of the keys to successful content market and social media engagements is the "freshness" and quality of the content. At TrendSpottr we have witnessed first hand that users who find and publish content from our site see immediate increases in their online engagement (eg., number of followers, retweets, shares, etc) and commensurate increases in their Klout score. The reason for this is that TrendSpottr identifies early trending content for any topic of interest. More specifically, the content "spotted" by TrendSpottr is at its earliest acceleration point (ie., very early in its information cycle), has algorithmically determined "trending value" (ie., viral growth potential) and has a much higher likelihood of engaging an audience. Try it out at and see if your content marketing improves. We think you'll be impressed by the results.
Colby Keeler 11:54 AM on November 11, 2011
Great Post! Fantastic reminder that the whole process consists of steps. You can plan all you want but you've got to be able to implement and control even better. Focus groups help considerably with this and can often be held online.
Wizims 3:10 PM on November 11, 2011
I've had this failure with some truly great articles.
Another reason I think you should add is the timing of publishing the post..
You should pay attention to the peak times of your target audience and publish the post accordingly (For RSS sake).
Great post btw, keep it up man!
Chad Luckie 2:16 PM on November 13, 2011
Great content is something that Google still has a hard time sorting through in my opinion, but then again if Google robots could truly sort good content from bad them Copy writers and SEO consultants would be out of jobs. For instance I blog about internet marketing on my blog http://www.chadluckie.com but I do not necessarily optimize it for search. I still consider it good content.
Pamela Decharo 5:04 AM on November 14, 2011
I'm working on my first blog and this list is very helpful. These are all the rules of good writing, actually, and it's comforting to know that I'm going in the right direction! Thanks so much...
Rohan Ranade 9:28 AM on November 14, 2011
The list doesnt work in Indian Context!!
Amit Sodha 11:02 AM on November 14, 2011
Hey there,
Your proof is in your pudding. As soon as I saw the title on twitter it caught my attention and straight away I had to retweet and have a good read.
Thank you so much for the pointers, every little bit is helpful. I feel like I've written some masterpieces (always open to opinion) that never got that much attention. I'll never give up though until I get it right!
Thanks again for the amazing piece!