Have ya heard? A new animal may be wreaking havoc on your ability to get found in search. But this time, it doesn't take the form of a black and white bear. No -- this time, it's even more deceptively cute and harmless. This time ... it's a penguin.
Last week on April 24, Google released a new update called Google Penguin to combat spammy web pages' ability to turn up in Google search results. In fact, you may remember a blog post we wrote last month that hinted this update was coming, conveyed as one meant to target and penalize sites that were "over-optimized" for search. While Google has now clarified that the update was engineered to be more about combatting outright spammy tactics rather than vague instances of "over-optimization," this is the update they were referring to back in March. The Penguin Update slams sites that employ such tactics as keyword stuffing, duplicate content, or misleading/hidden/cloaked links, all of which Google clearly warns against in its Webmaster Guidelines regarding quality.
So now that Google has confirmed that the new update is completely live, how can you tell if you've been bitten by an angry Penguin -- and what should you do about it if you have been? Google and Search Engine Land have both shared some great advice, so let's dig into what you can do if you're suffering from Penguin backlash.
(And honestly, is anyone else curious as to why Google is so enamored with naming its algorithm updates after black and white colored animals? What's next -- Google Zebra?)
How to Tell if You've Been Penalized by Google Penguin
Although there's no way to log in to Google Webmaster Central to determine if you've been hit, Search Engine Land suggests a quick little test you can conduct to get a sense of whether your website is suffering in search since the update was deployed. And, in fact, Google agrees this is the way to go:
Take a look at your website analytics, comparing your organic search traffic from Google a few days before and in the days after Google Penguin launched (April 24). Note: Don't be fooled by Google Panda! Google rolled out an update to Panda, called Panda 3.5, on April 19. This update targets low-quality, not spammy, websites. So if you notice that you were starting to get hurt in terms of organic search traffic prior to April 24, you probably have a Panda problem on your hands. In that case, refer to this post to learn what you can do about it. If you've ruled out Panda, you'll notice 1 of 3 scenarios pertaining to the Penguin Update:
- Do you notice a drop in traffic in the days after? If so, you likely have a Penguin problem.
- Do you notice traffic is staying the same? This means you probably weren't impacted by the update at all; you're probably safe!
- Do you notice a spike in traffic? This could mean you've actually benefited from the update. Perhaps some of your competitors were penalized by Penguin, and you're swiping some of the traffic that otherwise would've been routed to them. Nice!
If the latter two scenarios are what's playing out for you, then keep up the good work. You're probably doing a good job of playing by Google's guidelines and aren't participating in spammy SEO behavior. If the first scenario sounds more like your situation, keep reading ...
How to Treat Your Google Penguin Wounds
If you're getting hit because of a spammy web presence, you're going to need to clean up those instances of spam.
First things first. Have you verified your Google Webmaster Account yet? There's a chance that Google has already sent you messages regarding your spammy behavior, but if you've never verified your account, you may never have known they were sitting there waiting for you! In fact, Google has been ramping up its attempts to notify users through its Webmaster Tools, using it to send over 700,000 messages to webmasters in January and February 2012. That's more than the total number of message it sent in the whole of 2011!
So, after you've checked your messages, your next step should be to fix any spammy behavior Google flagged and notified you about in particular. But don't stop there. Read through those Google Webmaster Quality Guidelines we mentioned earlier and check your site for instances where you may be participating in some spammy behavior. Then, well, fix those instances! Here is what you should be looking out for as you're auditing your site:
Specific Quality Guidelines From Google (Source):
- Avoid hidden text or hidden links.
- Don't use cloaking or sneaky redirects.
- Don't send automated queries to Google.
- Don't load pages with irrelevant keywords (AKA keyword stuffing).
- Don't create multiple pages, subdomains, or domains with substantially duplicate content.
- Don't create pages with malicious behavior, such as phishing or installing viruses, trojans, or other badware.
- Avoid "doorway" pages created just for search engines, or other "cookie cutter" approaches such as affiliate programs with little or no original content.
If any of these spammy behaviors sound applicable to your website, correct them as soon as possible.
Can You Air Your Grievances if You Feel You've Been Wronged by Penguin?
You may notice there is a tempting link at the bottom of Google's Webmaster Guidelines through which you can 'submit your site for reconsideration' if you've modified it after determining that it didn't meet these guidelines, but here's the deal. Google has said the Penguin update will ding spammy sites automatically, not manually. In other words, submitting a reconsideration request won't do much because Google won't be making any manual exceptions.
If you feel like your site has been penalized unjustly, you're better off using this form to air your grievances to Google, which was created exclusively for users who feel they've been wronged by the Penguin Update. Just do so in a way that explains why your site shouldn't be considered spammy, not using an attitude that blames Google for being a bad guy.
If you know a site affected by algo update that you don't think should be affected, we made a form to provide feedback: goo.gl/nt3Pz
— Matt Cutts (@mattcutts) April 26, 2012
What's the Takeaway for Marketers?
You can easily get swept up in the technicalities of any new Google algorithm update, but the lesson is always the same: create remarkable content that's written for your audience first and search engines next, and follow best practices to ensure that Google can easily crawl, understand, and index that content.
Marketers who stick to genuine, white-hat techniques and always keep Google's guidelines in the back of their minds shoudln't have to worry about getting dinged by the algorithm update from Google.
And if it feels like a black hat SEO tactic, it probably is.
How do you feel about Google's new Penguin Update?
Image Credit: HighlandBlade



Ira Wolfe 9:11 AM on April 30, 2012
Thanks for the great summary. I can't say I was hit by Penguin but on March 14, give or take a day, my site traffic plummeted. With the exception of duplicate meta descriptions from almost 10 years ago that I've been correcting, I can't identify any other reasons. I had over 900 page indexed on my site plus another 700 blog articles. Any thought?
Ken Nairne 9:34 AM on April 30, 2012
Thank you for this article. It seems like Google is really trying to push out a lot of the small marketers who are trying to get a foothold in the online buseniss sector. And to name their new Update after a black and white bird - well, what can one say.
Thanks Pamela a great piece.
Ken
Ioannis 11:02 AM on April 30, 2012
The Pentium kicked my butt, Traffic crashed Down to 5-10%. Right now it is recovering, but very Slow like a wounded Panda :)
Shahzad Hassan 3:54 PM on April 30, 2012
@Lisa: 1-automated queries are generated by software to ping the Google server for calling the spider back to the site for re-indexing purpose. 2-the total number of words of an article when divided to the number of keyword repeated in the article it give the keyword density. the good density is 2.5 - 3.5%.
Ravi Mathews 3:57 AM on May 01, 2012
Thing is no one actually wants to employ any such tactic, however, you always find your competitors using all the 'methods' that Google often warns you against and ranking high attracting massive traffic and in turn money.
Rachel Roodhardt 5:58 AM on May 01, 2012
Great article -thanks very much. Got bitten by an angry penguin and this article has really helped (especially the date information!) Looks like I over egged my keyword density, but I only did it because it was the only way to get to the top!! I'll be glad if re-writing my site works because I hated putting all those extra keywords in, it just didn't read particularly well.
I wondered if the black and white animals was connected to black and white hat seo? My bet for the next name is Orca ;-)
Rachel Roodhardt 6:48 AM on May 01, 2012
Talking of spam... can we have a "report this as spam button" on the comments section...?
I'd rather like to panda a few of the spammers on this site (see Dolakh Thapa's comment above)
Giulia 1:02 PM on May 01, 2012
Difficult to say yet because the update has been released close to 2 bank holiday.
I saw my traffic dropping but not sure it depends on the Penguin update or just holidays. Next one will probably be the 23rd of December.
Analyst District 3:42 AM on May 02, 2012
Also don't forget branding! Branded sites are memorable and less vulnerable to search engine updates.
Professional Courses 2:11 AM on May 03, 2012
True. We have just started off our website and are trying to write as much informative content as possible. In fact, most of our articles are original (even though, we have very few right now). I think, its essential to understand that Black Hat SEO techniques only work in the short run. If you want to establish your business and are aiming for the long run, then it helps to build your rep online and be a bit patient, as SEO does take time.
Christina 12:42 PM on May 03, 2012
Thankfully sticking to white hat seems to have paid off for our clients who haven't been hit by this update.
Our main website has actually seen an increase in traffic YAY! But our testing site has seen a very small drop, which could be because I haven't been active in social media (need to do a bit more digging)
However, it was fantastic to see our competition who are black hat drop out of the rankings altogether. Even bigger YAY!
Go Google!
-Christina
DR Adept
Charles Sipe 2:17 PM on May 03, 2012
The Google Panda update was named after one of Google's engineers, Navneet Panda. I'm guessing Penguin is an extension of the animal theme. It seems like Google likes to have fun with their product updates, e.g. Honeycomb, Ice cream Sandwich, Panda.
Rita 3:48 PM on May 03, 2012
My website traffic hasnt plummeted, yet. But I recently created a mobile website, and I wanted mobile users to have the option to break out of it and get to the full site if they wish, so I use a javascript to take mobile users to a page where they are given a choice. non mobile users go to the full site. Is this considered cloaking? I could use a wordpress plugin to send mobile users to the mobile site but then they cannot break out of it to get to the full site... Unless I set a cookie, but I understand not all mobile devices accept cookies... Help!
Online Marketing Birmingham 4:48 AM on May 04, 2012
It was quite informative to know what the penguin is up to.I was in-fact finding and collecting all the articles on the topic as I am currently in the process of planning a strategy for SEO's to utilize.
I think this latest update has given us all some serious “food for thought". I personally believe that sites that stick to white hat SEO should survive this and any future updates without a scratch. Clearly, Google is going to do their best to catch every black hat and spammer they can!
Accountants in Brighton 6:45 AM on May 04, 2012
Thanks for this blog, really helped! We haven't suffered from the penguin update, but it's good to learn about what to avoid in future!
Thanks again.
Pamela Vaughan 3:03 PM on May 04, 2012
Rita: It sounds like you're in the clear, but here's an article Google wrote on the topic so you can be sure:
http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2009/11/running-desktop-and-mobile-versions-of.html
Basically, you can't show the Googlebot (web crawler) anything different that what you should show a web visitor, and you can't show Googlebot-Mobile (mobile crawler) anything different than what you would show a mobile viewer.
Rita 12:15 AM on May 05, 2012
Thanks, Pamela! I was on another web board and they had me all paranoid about it, and here I thought I was doing a pro-active thing allowing mobile devices to break out to get to the full site if they wished... Thank you for your insite, I didnt think I was doing anything wrong...
BilliO 9:29 AM on May 07, 2012
great article! very informative, although i must agree it mostly hurt the-not-that-white ;) SEO techniques while in my stats it seemed to do a little google dance into a whole new geo-targeted market... but i can only assume it's side effect of the after-penguin-math..
siobhan 12:20 PM on May 07, 2012
Of course, anything that helps clean up the spam on the web is great -- but I can't help but feel this really gives the established websites a HUGE advantage over start-ups -- anyone who comes up with something new or better will get linked by the press, but most people who just compete on better service or better price will find it hard to even get seen.